| PollID | Graph | Entrant 1 | Entrant 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | A / B / C | Sephiroth | Ganondorf |
| 2018 | A / B / C | Diablo | Ganondorf |
| 2017 | A / B / C | Bowser | Sephiroth |
| 2016 | A / B / C | Ganondorf | Dr. Robotnik |
| 2015 | A / B / C | Kefka | Diablo |
| 2014 | A / B / C | Sephiroth | Liquid Snake |
| 2013 | A / B / C | Bowser | Revolver Ocelot |
| 2012 | A / B / C | Dr. Robotnik | Master Hand |
| 2011 | A / B / C | Ganondorf | Ansem |
| 2010 | A / B / C | M. Bison | Diablo |
| 2009 | A / B / C | Kefka | Wesker |
| 2008 | A / B / C | Lavos | Liquid Snake |
| 2007 | A / B / C | Sephiroth | Vergil |
| 2006 | A / B / C | Revolver Ocelot | Dr. Wily |
| 2005 | A / B / C | Bowser | Sigma |
| 2004 | A / B / C | Kuja | Master Hand |
| 2003 | A / B / C | Dr. Robotnik | Sin |
| 2002 | A / B / C | Ansem | CATS |
| 2001 | A / B / C | Ganondorf | Giygas |
| 2000 | A / B / C | Ridley | Diablo |
| 1999 | A / B / C | Albedo | M. Bison |
| 1998 | A / B / C | Luca Blight | Wesker |
| 1997 | A / B / C | Kefka | Mithos |
| 1996 | A / B / C | Liquid Snake | Officer Tenpenny |
| 1995 | A / B / C | Lavos | Mother Brain |
| 1994 | A / B / C | Vergil | Ghaleon |
| 1993 | A / B / C | Sephiroth | Ramirez |
| 1992 | A / B / C | Dr. Wily | Ultros |
| 1991 | A / B / C | Revolver Ocelot | Nemesis |
| 1990 | A / B / C | Sigma | Andross |
| 1989 | A / B / C | Bowser | Pyramid Head |